Cherry Key Lime Marmalade

cherry-lime-marmaladeDoes anyone still have cherries? No? Me neither. Maybe Newfoundland? Or wait: my homies in Saskatchewan, this one’s for you!

I’m late with cherries this year: as usual. Seems to be a recurring theme. (Another recurring theme? I think I’m going to miss blueberries this year. AGAIN. Sigh.) In happy news, Fishkill Farms finally had a productive cherry season: we’ve only been waiting four years. In unhappy news, they were charging $7/lb: for pick-your-own. And while I had lots of fun on my trip there with Autumn oh-so many weeks ago, it happened to be in the middle of that crazy New York heat wave. It was hot. I mean HOT. 94 degree and 8 bizillion percent humidity hot. So, while we valiantly picked a few quarts each (and a few quarts of raspberries, too), I sort of resented those $7 quarts of cherries, gathered sweatily in the harsh summer sun. I guess we could say I had a little passive-aggressive cherry angst going on this year: I let those cherries sit & sit. And I didn’t search out any more, despite my ardent and abiding love for the best cherry preserve ever.

Luckily for me, Julia was on the ball. She had to be down this way a couple of weeks ago, as she was selling jams at an artisan market at the Williams-Sonoma in White Plains. She hooked me up with a half-bushel of cherries from her ‘hood (already picked and way, way less expensive, mind you). I dried about half of them, then made a HUGE batch of the best cherry preserve ever. Then I pitted the last 5 lbs, dropped them in some sugar, and tucked them in the fridge. Then, somehow… it was August.

Where has this summer gone? Is it the fact that it started off so cold and wet? An early June 10-day trip to Our Nation’s Capital? The fact that I’ve had tons of data to analyze and reports to write? Maybe a combination of all of the above. Or maybe just proof that I really am getting old: the days. They just fly by. And here we are, just one day away from yet another trip this year, back out to my peeps in San Francisco, to celebrate my friend Melissa’s 50th(!) birthday in wine country, and to generally create a Ruckus By The Bay. SF: be warned. The Redhead Cometh.

But, before I fly off to Points West: cherry key lime marmalade. I know, I know: who makes marmalade in August? Who preserves cherries in August? Days-are-flying-by-way-too-fast girl, that’s who. And, I’ve gotta say, it was kinda fun, a-marmin’ in the summertime. (Think I’m going to start a white girl rap band. Our debut album? A-Marmin’ In The Summertime.) As for this marm: it’s really quite delightful. The recipe below makes an enormous batch: it easily could (and probably should) be cut in half, if, like most of the world, you’re running a bit low on cherries in August. <ahem> But, it’s tangy and tart and beautifully magenta with plenty of whole cherries and vibrant green citrus slices: this one will definitely wake up your taste buds. Yo.

cherry-lime-marmaladeCherry Key Lime Marmalade


  • 2 lbs sweet cherries, stemmed & pitted
  • 2 ½ lbs sugar (organic evaporated cane juice)
  • 8 oz key limes, halved, seeded and thinly sliced
  • 8 oz (about 3 medium) regular limes, quartered, seeded and thinly sliced
  • water
  • 3 to 4 stems fresh lemon verbena (Special thanks go to Autumn for gifting me her homegrown verbena!)
  • large pinch sea salt


  1. Day 1. Combine cherries and sugar in a large, wide preserving pan or stock pot. Bring to a simmer over medium heat, stirring until sugar dissolves. Simmer 5 minutes, then cool to room temperature, transfer to a bowl, cover tightly and refrigerate overnight.
  2. Measure sliced limes into a 4-cup measure (my yield was 3 cups). In a large saucepan or deep skillet, combine lime slices with an equal volume of water. Add lemon verbena stems. Bring to a simmer over high heat. Reduce heat to low, cover, and simmer for 10 minutes. Cool to room temperature, transfer to a bowl (separate from the cherries), cover tightly and refrigerate overnight.
  3. Day 2. Prepare canner, jars and lids.
  4. Combine macerated cherries and lime mixture in a large, wide preserving pot. Remove lemon verbena stems. Add pinch of salt. Bring to a boil over high heat. Continue to boil, stirring only minimally, until marmalade reaches the set point: 220 degrees F on an instant thermometer, or a small dollop wrinkles on the frozen plate test. Turn off heat. Ladle hot marmalade into hot jars to ¼-inch headspace. Bubble jars, wipe rims, affix lids and process in a boiling water bath for 10 minutes.

Yields 10 cups.


  1. I added more sugar to this marmalade than I normally would: I started at 2 lbs sugar, but tasted throughout the cooking and added another cup, in increments, before I was happy with the flavor. The final product is still quite tart: your mileage may vary, depending on the sweetness of your cherries and the tartness of your limes.
  2. No reason this shouldn’t work well with frozen cherries. And, I happened to luck into a small bag of key limes, but if you can only find regular, those will do fine.
  3. Fresh lemon verbena can be hard to find: I do think it lends a certain floral something to the final product, but if you can’t find it, feel free to omit.


Canned, store in a cool, dark spot for up to 1 year.


Summer, or year-round with frozen cherries.


  1. What a beautiful flavour combination! I would never have thought of adding key limes to cherries in marmalade but the picture is evidence enough that it works! Love that first photo… sticky, sweet fruity goodness. Definitely trying this when we get our summer glut of cherries (it’s winter here at the moment, so I luckily get to review all of the summery recipes in the blogosphere before our seasonal fruit arrives… uh, whilst getting jealous of your gorgeous weather and summer fruit. But I’ll forget the last part!) xx

  2. I’m not a marmalade fan but the addition of cherries might win me over. $7/lb at Fishkill for pick your own?! Wow, I was hoping to pick cherries this year but the timing didn’t work out. I think I was able to score $5/lb at my farmers markets. Usually you expect pick your own to be cheaper, since you know, you’re doing the labor. Oh well, think cherries are totally gone now but definitely saving this for next year. Thanks!

  3. EL

    Well, we are in the middle of cherry season here in Montana. And the weather (knock on wood) seems to be about perfect. I am baking clafoutis with mine. Yum! So come on out. Cherries are 2 — 3 dollars per lb here. If you bring the key limes with you (or any type of lime) you could make a lot more marmalade. . .

Leave a Reply to Melissa Brody Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: